False Claims About My Representation Of Wolf Facts
May 1, 2009
I get on a regular basis emails from readers accusing me a many things, aside from the insults and name calling. For the hundredth time the other day I got another email that accused me of writing about wolves and elk that weren’t true, that I was fear mongering by telling readers that wolves where destroying elk herds.
What was typical in this particular email is what I’ve learned to come to expect that often times readers may only land on this site, read an article or two but more times than not skim over and select parts and pieces from here and there and then form conclusions. As a result, I make an attempt to write accordingly to cover recaps and provide links. The truth is I can’t do all the readers’ work for them and therefore I must deal with the results. Read more
What’s in HB 228?
May 1, 2009
Several of you have emailed me to ask what we actually got when the Governor signed HB 228.
Here’s what we got:
1. A clear policy statement by the Legislature that self defense is a natural right and that self defense by citizens reduces crime.
2. A clear policy statement by the Legislature that the right to bear arms in Montana is a fundamental (important legal term) and individual right.
3. Reversal of guilty-until-proven-innocent for people defending themselves. This provision requires the state to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a person defending herself or himself was NOT justified in using force, rather than before, that defenders must have proven that they were justified in using force. Trust me, this is very important.
4. Legislative declaration of policy that a defender has no duty to summon help or flee before using force to defend, in any place the defender is lawfully.
5. Open carry is legal. This has been presumed in Montana, but never stated in law. People have been arrested for open carry. HB 228 will settle that issue for good.
6. A defender may announce “I have a gun,” with no more fear of prosecution under Montana’s overbroad felony “Intimidation” statute.
7. Defensive display. A person may show an attacker that the defender is armed, and may even draw the gun and still be clearly on the right side of the legal line if the defender genuinely fears attack.
8. Requirement that when police investigate a scene where self defense is claimed, investigators must collect evidence that may support a claim of self defense as well as any other evidence.
9. Improved conditions for a defender to use force in any occupied structure. This applies to all occupied structures, not just a dwelling.
10. Police may not destroy any firearms seized. Any firearms seized must either be returned to the rightful owner or sold back into the marketplace.
11. Landlords may not prevent tenants from possessing firearms. This not only protects travelers staying in motels, but also protects those who cannot afford to own their own homes.
12. Restoration of the right to bear arms for people convicted of non-violent crimes who have done their time and been released from state supervision. This will not apply to a person who committed a crime of violence or a crime where a weapon was used.
13. The ability to use reasonable force to effect the citizen’s arrest of a person believed to have committed a crime – to be able to hold the person until law enforcement can be summoned (as happened recently in Thompson Falls).
14. An immediate effective date. All of this became effective while the ink from the Governor’s signature was drying.
All in all, that’s quite a bit.
Gary Marbut, president
Montana Shooting Sports Association
http://www.mtssa.org
author, Gun Laws of Montana
http://www.mtpublish.com
